When the Sun Began to Set

In the fall of 1997, I began the process of becoming a United Methodist pastor.

I was young, eager, and convinced that God had called me into ministry. I didn't know exactly where that road would lead, but I understood the path I was supposed to follow.

Serve in a local church. Go to seminary. Complete the requirements. Become ordained. Receive appointments. Lead congregations.

And that's precisely what I did.

By 2016, I had spent nearly twenty years pursuing that calling. I had served multiple churches, earned my Master of Divinity, been ordained an Elder, and helped launch a thriving new worshiping community.

I had invested nearly my entire adult life in becoming the kind of pastor I thought I was supposed to be.

But somewhere along the way, the path that had once seemed so clear began to feel increasingly unfamiliar.

The questions that had been troubling me weren't going away.

If I believed God was calling me to invest more intentionally in the discipleship of men, how could I continue giving the majority of my time and attention to something else?

I wasn't questioning whether God had called me into ministry.

I was questioning whether the particular expression of ministry I had spent twenty years pursuing was still where He wanted me.

That's a difficult distinction when your calling and your career have become so closely intertwined.

It was like watching the sun set.

At first, the light changes so gradually that you barely notice. The landscape is still familiar. You can still see the road ahead.

But eventually you realize the day is ending.

And no amount of wishing will make the sun stand still.

In February 2016, I told my supervisors that I believed God was calling me toward a different kind of ministry. I requested a transition into extension ministry, an arrangement that would allow me to remain connected to the denomination while stepping away from a traditional pastoral appointment in June.

There was just one catch.

I would have to support myself.

No guaranteed salary. No familiar financial structure. And no clear explanation of what I was stepping into.

Around that time, another opportunity emerged. A church in Lexington offered me the chance to help launch a new worship venue. It was the kind of work I knew how to do, with the security of an established institution behind it.

The alternative was to move home to the family farm and start from scratch, pursuing a ministry I could barely explain, much less guarantee would succeed.

I made a list with two columns. The left column represented the new appointment. Almost everything about it was certain. A salary. A familiar role. An established church.

The second column represented moving home and beginning something new. Almost everything about it was a question mark. No salary. No leads. Just faith.

Looking at those columns, I thought the responsible choice was obvious.

But Amanda helped me see something I was overlooking.

We both knew the toll that ministry had taken on our family. We lived halfway between our jobs, without a real sense of community where we made our home. Our kids had their school world and their church world, but those worlds rarely intersected. It often felt like we lived one life during the week and another on Sunday.

I knew the strain. I felt it, too. But I had grown accustomed to accepting it as part of the calling.

Amanda challenged me to reconsider what faithfulness required of me, not only as a pastor, but as a husband and father.

And she was right.

I had been so focused on discerning the next step in ministry that I was once again considering sacrificing my family on the altar of ministry.

What had seemed like an opportunity was beginning to look more like a distraction. Amanda's discernment didn't make the road ahead any more certain, but it helped me recognize that the familiar path wasn't necessarily the faithful one.

On June 12, 2016, I preached my final Sunday at Belin.

I loved those people, and they had loved me well. Leaving was painful.

I wasn't walking away from the Church or from pastoral ministry.

I was stepping away from a vocational path I had once assumed I would follow for the rest of my life.

And I had very little idea what would happen next.

Looking back, I can see something I couldn't fully appreciate then.

The sun wasn't merely setting on one season.

Another was beginning to rise.

I just couldn't see it yet.

Scott Allen Johnson

Scott Allen Johnson is the founder and Executive Director of the Corban Collective, with over 25 years of ministry experience. He believes every man has a calling, something to contribute, and someone worth investing in. Through faith, adventure, and authentic brotherhood, Scott helps men live intentionally and multiply their influence as disciples of Jesus.

Previous
Previous

The Holy Discontent

Next
Next

The Wilderness was not Wasted